Oh, the sweet dilemma of choosing the perfect cherry pie! It's a classic dessert that can make or break a grocery store's reputation. And so, we embark on a journey to uncover the best store-bought cherry pies, ranked from worst to best. Get ready for a mouth-watering adventure!
But here's where it gets controversial...
Giant Eagle Market District Cherry Pie: A pricey disappointment. While the lattice crust looked enticing, it was chewy and stale, even fresh from the store. The filling lacked the right balance of cherries and gel, leaving the pie dry. It's a dessert that screams for ice cream and milk to save the day.
See AlsoTaco Bell's New Luxe Value Menu: 10 Items Under $3! (Launching Jan 22)Snickers Mini Ice Cream Bars Review: All 5 Flavors Taste Tested!Exploring Japan's Expensive Convenience Store Onigiri: Are They Worth the Price?Japanese Ice Cream Seller Arrested in Chiang Mai: Unpermitted Business or Discrimination?Sara Lee Cherry Pie: A frozen disappointment. Despite its decades-old recipe, the pie fell flat with a graham cracker-colored crust that crumbled easily. The cherries were sour, and the pie lacked juiciness. However, it beats Giant Eagle's version in freshness and price.
Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Traditional Cherry Pie: A no-frills option. The crust is solid, and the cherries burst with each bite, offering a tart-sweet balance. It's a standard pie, nothing extraordinary, but it satisfies cravings. Warming it up can bring back some freshness.
Table Talk Old Fashioned Cherry Pie: A tiny pie with a big personality. At 4 inches, it's the perfect personal pie. The crust is soft and reminiscent of a sugar cookie. The filling is mostly goop with a few crushed cherries, but it has a bright fruity flavor. It's decent, but lacks the balance and indulgence of other pies.
Fresh from Meijer Cherry Pie: A unique crust sets this pie apart. It resembles a golden croissant, smooth and rich. The filling, however, tastes canned, lacking real cherries. It's a satisfying pie, but the filling could use more body and freshness.
Marie Callender's Lattice Cherry Pie: A frozen delight. The cherries are tangy and succulent, hidden under a lattice crust. The lattice offers a great balance, preventing the pie from feeling too doughy. The only downside is the slightly gummy and undercooked middle, which could have benefited from a few extra minutes in the oven.
Kroger Private Selection Triple Cherry Pie: The winner! This pie is a cherry lover's dream. The aroma of three different cherries fills the air. The darker cherries add a rich, complex flavor, almost like a strawberry-cherry candy. The crust is buttery and soft, with a light crisp. It's a delicious balance of flavors, and it comes in a convenient half-pie size too!
And this is the part most people miss...
The key to a great cherry pie is the balance between a flaky, buttery crust and a generous amount of plump, juicy cherries. A little gel is welcome, but it shouldn't overpower the pie. Now, what do you think? Which pie would you choose? Let's discuss in the comments and share our favorite store-bought cherry pie experiences!
